Immigration Detention Centers' Harsh Effects on Immigrant Mental Health
Immigration deportations have always been a cause for concern; unfortunately, the mental health effects are rarely brought to attention. When someone is detained by the Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers, they are held in a detention center. This is almost like a prison where people are detained until their immigration status can be properly addressed. With the recent surges in ICE detentions, it is important to take note of the effects prolonged detention can have on both the mental and physical health of immigrants. The research study Duration in Immigration Detention and Health Harms shows that spending more than 6 months in a detention center can have detrimental effects such as post-traumatic stress, mental illness, and worsened physical well-being. The amount of time someone spends in a detention center can progressively deteriorate their mental health.
While in these detention centers, detainees face similar situations to those in incarceration centers. Cruel conditions such as malnutrition, sleep deprivation, and isolation from support systems are indirectly harmful to detainees. Along with this, there are also direct harms that are both physical and psychological. Threats to an individual's safety due to abuse from the guards and disciplinary practices, such as isolation, also serve as part of the brutal conditions these people face. These acts of abuse, unfortunately, have to be endured as they have no say in how they are treated. For individuals who have pre-existing trauma, this mistreatment heightens their vulnerability to the harms of incarceration. Essentially, since they are more vulnerable, the brutal conditions might affect them more severely than others because they might suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). These situations can be triggering for them.
While in these detention centers, detainees face similar situations to those in incarceration centers. Cruel conditions such as malnutrition, sleep deprivation, and isolation from support systems are indirectly harmful to detainees. Along with this, there are also direct harms that are both physical and psychological. Threats to an individual's safety due to abuse from the guards and disciplinary practices, such as isolation, also serve as part of the brutal conditions these people face. These acts of abuse, unfortunately, have to be endured as they have no say in how they are treated. For individuals who have pre-existing trauma, this mistreatment heightens their vulnerability to the harms of incarceration. Essentially, since they are more vulnerable, the brutal conditions might affect them more severely than others because they might suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). These situations can be triggering for them.
People who are held in detention centers can begin to have symptoms of anxiety and depression.
Image Source: Mohamed Hassan
Unfortunately, detention centers operate under civil immigration law, unlike prisons that operate under criminal law. The main difference between these two laws is that in prisons, individuals receive a sentence under criminal law. In detention centers, since it is a civil matter, there is no set time a person has to be released by, so they can stay indefinitely. This can lead to prolonged stays with no hope of being released and no escape from their mental struggles. One of the findings included a dose-response relationship, which in this context suggests that the longer an individual spends in a detention center, the worse their symptoms may be.
Staying for six or fewer months in the detention center could result in a decline in physical and mental health. Around 40% of the participants felt their health was “poor” after spending more than six months or fewer in these detention centers. However, anything longer than six months seems to be increasingly detrimental. About 50% of participants said they believed their health was in poor condition after spending more than six months in detention centers. Being held for more than six months causes higher rates of post-traumatic stress disorder, anxiety, depression, and psychological stress.
Ultimately, the damage caused by the immigration detention centers continues far beyond what is endured within those walls. The longer they are forced to stay, the more severe the consequences become. The people held in detention centers are exposed to conditions that slowly deteriorate both their mental and physical health.
Staying for six or fewer months in the detention center could result in a decline in physical and mental health. Around 40% of the participants felt their health was “poor” after spending more than six months or fewer in these detention centers. However, anything longer than six months seems to be increasingly detrimental. About 50% of participants said they believed their health was in poor condition after spending more than six months in detention centers. Being held for more than six months causes higher rates of post-traumatic stress disorder, anxiety, depression, and psychological stress.
Ultimately, the damage caused by the immigration detention centers continues far beyond what is endured within those walls. The longer they are forced to stay, the more severe the consequences become. The people held in detention centers are exposed to conditions that slowly deteriorate both their mental and physical health.
Featured Image Source: Mohamed Hassan
RELATED ARTICLES
|
Vertical Divider
|
Vertical Divider
|
Vertical Divider
|